James, another former classmate, finds himself next on Molly's "hit list" when he receives an e-mail promising a grim escape from "reality". Struggling to care for his ailing mother, he's hesitant to engage, though Sam and Ethan's call to action may prove irresistible. Later, the discovery of a key figure from Molly's past could shed light on her disappearance, if only they can find him.