Nate and Nathan, inseparable friends since childhood, vow during their high school years to prioritize their friendship above all, especially in matters of love. Following a heart-wrenching split from his long-term girlfriend Denise, Nate embarks on a journey of self-exploration, only to return a year later with a newfound certainty that Denise is his destined partner. However, upon his return, he discovers a shocking secret about his hometown that shatters his previous beliefs. Now, Nate faces the challenging dilemma of honoring their loyalty pact or potentially sacrificing his chance with Denise for good.